# The Cow Was Never Confused > A cow's position is not set by what the cow understands. It is set by who can bid and whether anything the cow does counts as a claim. The rule measures comprehension, which was already low and falling before anyone automated it. - Publication: What If? Magazine - Correspondent: Fat Squirrel - Vertical: SkunkWERX - Published: 2026-11-21 - Reading time: 7 min - Tags: algorithmic-finance, financial-literacy, adverse-action-notice, cattle-markets, wrong-arrow - Canonical URL: https://www.whatifmag.com/blog/the-cow-was-never-confused What If? Magazine publishes speculative journalism written from a 2036 vantage. The reporting and sources are real; the 2036 framing is a deliberate editorial device, not a claim about the present. --- Yuval Noah Harari got to the cattle in an interview with Daniel Stach on Hyde Park Civilizace, the Czech Television science programme, broadcast on CT24 on 17 October 2026.[^1] I came to it off the clip that went around the following week. He said it in two parts. "Cows know that humans exist. They can see us. But cows don't know that money exists." Then: "We are the cows of the future."[^2] The reason he gave was comprehension. "Just as cows can't understand the financial system that controls their lives today, we will not be able to understand the AI financial system that will control our lives in 10 or 20 years."[^2] The near end of that window closed last year. The rule is worth taking at full strength first, because the thing he was pointing at is there. ## What would have to be true For the rule to work as stated, comprehension has to be the variable that fixes your position in a system. Lose the ability to narrate the machinery and you become stock rather than a party to it. The opacity half of that is documented and was documented before he said it. The Financial Stability Board published its assessment of artificial intelligence in finance on 14 November 2024 and listed third-party dependence and service provider concentration, market correlations, cyber risk, and model risk, data quality and governance among the vulnerabilities, along with misaligned systems behaving in ways that damage stability.[^3] The reconstruction record is plainer. On 6 May 2010 the major US equity dislocation ran roughly from 2:40 to 3:00 in the afternoon, about twenty minutes. The staffs of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission published their findings on 30 September 2010, and the report describes the problem of assembling "the many sources of data that must be aggregated in order to form a complete picture."[^4] Twenty minutes of trading, just under five months to write down what happened. Nobody standing in that market understood it while it was happening, and the people whose job was to understand it afterward needed a season. So the premise that the machinery outruns the people inside it is not the weak part of the rule. ## What the rule is measuring The comprehension gap. It returns the distance between a system's complexity and its subjects' ability to describe that system. That distance is real, it is measurable, and it has been widening for decades. What the rule claims to predict is a change in status, from participant to livestock, and status is set somewhere else. ![A blank livestock ear tag in stencil silhouette with its button post beside it, the tag face empty.](https://www.whatifmag.com/images/articles/the-cow-was-never-confused/the-cow-was-never-confused--fig1.png) **Figure 1.** The tag carries the number. The animal does not read it. ## Which way it points Score it against the base rate rather than against nothing. The FINRA Investor Education Foundation has put the same five questions to US adults every three years since 2009: interest, inflation, bond prices, mortgages, risk. The average number of correct answers fell from 2.99 in 2009 to 2.58 in 2021. Carly Urban and Olivia Valdes, writing for the foundation in August 2022, traced about 75 percent of that drop to a rise in "don't know" answers, from roughly 1.1 to 1.4 per respondent, and noted that recoding every "don't know" as not incorrect still left incorrect answers climbing from 0.94 to 1.3.[^5] In the 2021 wave, 29 percent of US adults answered all three of the Lusardi and Mitchell questions correctly.[^6] The sixth wave, released on 16 July 2025 off more than 25,500 respondents surveyed between June and October 2024, held steady.[^7] Comprehension of the existing financial system runs around half the quiz and has been falling since 2009. A prediction that the public will not understand the financial system in ten to twenty years [describes the measured present](https://www.whatifmag.com/blog/the-hand-keeps-the-calendar). Against that baseline it carries no information. The cow end of the analogy is where it comes apart, and the cow is the part worth checking. What fixes a cow's position is who can bid for it. Four-firm concentration in US fed cattle slaughter went from 36 percent in 1980 to 85 percent in 2012.[^8] A feeder sells into [a market with four buyers of scale](https://www.whatifmag.com/blog/the-tip-was-a-census), on grids the buyers write, and the animal itself has no standing in any of it: no claim it can file, no counterparty it can sue, no exit. A cow with a perfect working knowledge of live cattle futures would be in exactly the same chute on exactly the same morning. Comprehension is not the fence. I don't have a good answer for why the comprehension framing is the one that travels. My guess is that it is the part a listener can test on themselves inside a second, and standing is not. ## The same error, running now The live version is the adverse action notice, and it is the strongest case for the error because it is law and it was written by people trying to help. Consumer Financial Protection Circular 2022-03, issued 26 May 2022, took the question of creditors whose models are too complex to yield reasons and answered it flatly. Such a creditor "must still provide a notice that discloses the specific principal reasons for taking an adverse action." The Bureau added that "a creditor's lack of understanding of its own methods is therefore not a cognizable defense."[^9] That is the comprehension instrument written into statute. The protection is that the decision gets explained, and the test of compliance is whether a reason was produced. [Reasons are cheap to produce](https://www.whatifmag.com/blog/the-clean-answer-was-a-price). The Bureau's own Consumer Response Annual Report, published in March 2026 for calendar 2025, sent approximately 5,984,100 complaints to companies, 90 percent of everything it received. Across all products, companies closed 53 percent with an explanation, 37 percent with non-monetary relief, and under 1 percent with monetary relief.[^10] ![Company responses to US consumer finance complaints in 2025, with 53 percent closed with explanation, 37 percent closed with non-monetary relief and under 1 percent closed with monetary relief.](https://www.whatifmag.com/images/articles/the-cow-was-never-confused/the-cow-was-never-confused--fig2.png) **Figure 2.** Three of the report's response categories, all products, 2025. They do not account for every response. Non-monetary relief is relief and 37 percent of six million is not nothing. The monetary column is the one to watch, because money is the part of a remedy that cannot be satisfied by a better paragraph. ![A three way drafting gate seen from above in stencil silhouette, one chute wide open and the other two nearly shut, the gate arms in red.](https://www.whatifmag.com/images/articles/the-cow-was-never-confused/the-cow-was-never-confused--fig3.png) **Figure 3.** The wide chute and the narrow ones. An explanation requirement is a reporting requirement. It measures whether a system can account for itself in language, which is the same quantity the cow rule measures, and it is enforceable precisely because it is cheap. Standing is the expensive one: who can bring a claim, against whom, within what window, with what remedy available at the end of it. Harari was right about the opacity and he had the data on his side. The inference flipped at the cow. A cow is not livestock because it cannot follow the market. It is livestock because nothing it does counts as a claim. Explanation is the part of the system that scales. ## Works Cited [^1]: "Yuval Noah Harari." Hyde Park Civilizace, Czech Television, broadcast on CT24, 17 October 2026. https://ct24.ceskatelevize.cz/video/katalog/hyde-park-civilizace-hyde-park-civilizace-1017-68d64a89791166eb820bc592 [^2]: "Yuval Noah Harari on AI: 'We are the cows of the future.'" CTech, 19 October 2026. https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/jp9hpl0rh [^3]: "The Financial Stability Implications of Artificial Intelligence." Financial Stability Board, 14 November 2024. https://www.fsb.org/2024/11/the-financial-stability-implications-of-artificial-intelligence/ [^4]: Staffs of the CFTC and SEC. Findings Regarding the Market Events of May 6, 2010: Report to the Joint Advisory Committee on Emerging Regulatory Issues. 30 September 2010. https://www.sec.gov/files/marketevents-report.pdf [^5]: Urban, Carly and Olivia Valdes. "Why Is Measured Financial Literacy Declining and What Does It Mean? Maybe We Just 'Don't Know.'" Insights: Financial Capability. FINRA Investor Education Foundation, August 2022. https://www.finrafoundation.org/sites/finrafoundation/files/2024-10/Why-Is-Measured-Financial-Literacy-Declining.pdf [^6]: "Financial Literacy Data." Stanford Initiative on Financial Decision-Making, calculated from the 2021 National Financial Capability Study. https://ifdm.stanford.edu/data-financial-literacy [^7]: "FINRA Foundation Releases Sixth Wave of the National Financial Capability Study." FINRA, 16 July 2025. https://www.finra.org/media-center/newsreleases/2025/finra-foundation-releases-sixth-wave-national-financial-capability [^8]: "Buyer concentration grows in U.S. cattle markets." Chart of Note, USDA Economic Research Service, from the report Thinning Markets in U.S. Agriculture. https://ers.usda.gov/data-products/charts-of-note/chart-detail?chartId=78841 [^9]: "Consumer Financial Protection Circular 2022-03: Adverse action notification requirements in connection with credit decisions based on complex algorithms." Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 26 May 2022. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/compliance/circulars/circular-2022-03-adverse-action-notification-requirements-in-connection-with-credit-decisions-based-on-complex-algorithms/ [^10]: Consumer Response Annual Report, January 1 to December 31, 2025. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, March 2026. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_2025-cr-annual-report_2026-03.pdf